# HOMEDRAW™ (working name) — CONCEPT SHEET v0.1 A successor concept to Equity Flow™, redesigned against the full Stage 1–5 diligence record (see `../ANALYSIS.md`). Design rule: keep the three product requirements — (A) monthly cash flow to the homeowner, (B) no forced sale, (C) capital recovered only at a liquidity event, homeowner keeps ownership — and surrender every feature the panel identified as a kill. **One-sentence product:** A deferred-interest, non-recourse, second-lien **loan** that pays the homeowner a fixed monthly draw, requires no payments of any kind until sale, death, refinance, or a stated 30-year maturity, is available at any age, and leaves the homeowner 100% of their home's appreciation. **Positioning:** "A paycheck from your house. No payments until you sell. Any age. It's a loan — we say so plainly — and you keep every dollar of your home's growth." --- ## 1. Core mechanics - **Instrument:** closed-end loan secured by a recorded second-lien deed of trust / mortgage. Openly and everywhere characterized as a loan: TILA/Reg Z disclosures, state lending licenses, recorded security instrument. No characterization wager anywhere in the stack. - **Draws:** fixed committed monthly advance (e.g., $1,500/mo) for a contracted draw period (e.g., 84 months), funded from a bankruptcy-remote funding trust holding committed capital for the full draw schedule (homeowner is never an unsecured creditor of the sponsor — cures estate 6.2). - **Interest:** fixed rate (target 9.0–9.75%), accruing ONLY on amounts actually drawn, compounding monthly, all payment deferred. Voluntary partial or full prepayment allowed at any time with no penalty (homeowner can stop or slow the accrual whenever they choose). - **Maturity / repayment:** due at the earlier of voluntary sale, cash-out refinance, death-triggered disposition, or a **stated 30-year legal-final maturity**. No forced settlement before then; at maturity, refinance or sale on the homeowner's schedule within a 12-month workout window. - **Non-recourse:** repayment capped at net sale proceeds after senior payoff and bona fide costs of sale; no deficiency, ever; heirs never personally liable. - **Draw Limit instead of Market Pause:** draws stop only when the accrued balance reaches a **pre-agreed dollar Draw Limit fixed at closing** (underwritten so projected CLTV at the end of the draw period ≤ ~75%). The trigger is an objective number printed in the closing documents — no counterparty-run AVM, no quarterly model, no dispute appraisals, nothing for a distressed lender to shop (cures ops 1.4, red-team F1/M1, retail T3/T9 in their entirety). - **No appreciation share. No ratchet. No 1.0x-plus-share. No Equity Shield.** The lender's return is the disclosed interest rate; the homeowner keeps 100% of appreciation. ## 2. Consumer protections (built in, not bolted on) - All-titleholder and all-spouse execution; capacity attestation; independent counseling required for applicants 62+ and offered to all. - **No occupancy default.** Primary residence required at origination and during the draw period only (moving out simply ends remaining draws — not a default). After the draw period the homeowner may rent, relocate, or age into care with no consequence except continued accrual. (Deletes the dementia-default / elder-abuse surface — estate 2.2, red-team H2.) - Death: standard mortgage law. The lien rides through probate; heirs get the customary payoff/assumption/refinance options plus the non-recourse cap; Garn-St Germain heir protections apply natively (it is a lien — (d)(1) safe harbor now fits cleanly). - Interest statements annually AND a real-time balance portal; every statement shows the payoff number and the Draw Limit headroom. The growing balance is the headline disclosure, not a buried term: scenario-table dollar disclosures at 5/10/20/30 years in the statutory HEI-table format (no home-brewed "APR-equivalent"). - No mandatory arbitration clause (moot anyway under §1639c(e) for a dwelling-secured loan). Standard mortgage-servicing rules accepted. - Rate-and-term refinance subordination: published policy, binding 10-business-day executed-subordination SLA carried by a permanent servicer-of-record with recorded assignments (title fixes 3–4 adopted). ## 3. Underwriting Same funnel, cleaner box: current CLTV ≤ 60%; projected CLTV at draw-period end (all draws + accrual) ≤ 75%; senior mortgage current, 12-month clean history; lock-in-score targeting for marketing ONLY — no demographic inputs, no eligibility gating without an FCRA adverse-action framework (ops 2.3 / sec-cf xe D3 adopted). Primary residence, any age, no income/DTI test (deferred product) but ability-to-pay-taxes/insurance verified. ## 4. Where the edge is 1. **Unoccupied product shape:** tenure-style monthly income with zero required payments exists today only inside HECM (62+, FHA friction). HELOCs require payments; lump-sum HEIs have no monthly option and force term settlement. The under-62 locked-in homeowner has no product. Ours is that product, honestly labeled. 2. **"Settle whenever life settles" — kept, legitimately.** A loan due at sale/death has no term settlement by construction. We keep the best-tested consumer promise from Equity Flow with none of its legal architecture. 3. **Staged deployment as pricing weapon:** ratable draws average roughly half the outstanding capital of a lump sum, so at equal target yield we can beat lump-sum HEI effective cost to the consumer (validated: investor xe D4). 4. **Securitizable by design:** stated 30-year legal final, fixed accrual rate, standard mortgage collateral file. This paper can seek a rating; HEI ride-along paper structurally cannot (actuarial 3.2). Target funding: warehouse → rated securitization; insurance private placement with **Schedule B (mortgage loan) treatment** rather than Schedule BA — the RBC arithmetic that killed the Tier 2 thesis may invert for a real mortgage loan with defined terms (actuarial to confirm). 5. **Distribution/data:** the Noteworth education funnel and lock-in targeting, aimed at the same segment, with a simpler one-sentence product. ## 5. Deliberately excluded (with the finding that killed each) | Excluded | Why (finding) | |---|---| | "Not a loan" positioning | tax P-1/D-1; sec-cf 3.1; title 1.2 | | Appreciation share + 1.0x floor | SAM confession; Roberts loss-sharing test | | Ratchet | actuarial 5.1 (useless to investor) + retail C3/P1 (toxic to consumer) | | Market pause / AVM trigger | ops 1.4; red-team F1/M1 | | Equity Shield | actuarial 1.1–1.4; sec-cf 1.6 | | Occupancy default regime | estate 2.2; red-team H2 | | Arbitration + class waiver | §1639c(e); McGill | | Non-lien memorandum | estate 4.1; title 1.2 | | Fee on projected draws / gross basis | ops 1.2; retail T6 — fee here is financed points on actual draws, disclosed | ## 6. Honest costs and open questions (for this review) - **Negative amortization is the product.** Balance grows; that is the reverse-mortgage optics problem, mitigated by non-recourse cap, 100% appreciation retention, voluntary prepayment, and hard Draw Limit — but it is the #1 consumer-perception and UDAAP-framing question. - **Texas:** monthly advances likely collide with Tex. Const. §50(t)(6) ($4,000 minimum advance) and §50(a)(6) mechanics — assume TX excluded at launch unless counsel finds a compliant structure. - **State reverse-mortgage statutes with functional definitions** may capture the product regardless of age gate → counseling/licensing costs where they do (sec-cf 4). Federal Reg Z §1026.33 reverse-mortgage classification: to be confirmed (it may actually help — ATR exemption). - **Funding is the moat and the risk:** who warehouses and who buys 10–25yr PIK mortgage paper pre-rating? Phantom income (OID accrual) for taxable holders. What rate do we need to charge for the capital stack to work, and is that rate still a consumer-acceptable product? - **Usury:** fixed 9–9.75% deferred, non-recourse — confirm headroom state-by-state with licensed-lender exemptions. - **Competitive response:** incumbents/banks can copy; the bet is (a) first to rated takeout for this paper, (b) funnel CAC advantage. Is that enough? **Base-case sketch (for the reviewers to attack):** $1,500/mo × 84 draws = $126,000 drawn; at 9.5% deferred, balance ≈ $160K at draw-period end, ≈ $276K at year 13, hits a $300K Draw-Limit-style cap only via accrual after year ~14; homeowner sells year 12 at 3% HPA ($891K home): payoff ≈ $250K, homeowner keeps home appreciation of ~$266K in full plus received $126K in draws. Lender IRR = 9.5% by construction, minus funding, servicing (50bps strip financed in rate), origination cost, and credit/timing losses. END OF CONCEPT SHEET v0.1