Data room / Run 2: prepared, never dispatched

Question list for run 2

Work assignment, 2,904 words, about 13 min to read

Questions drawn from an outside critique of the public site and routed to eight of the nine reviewers.

run-2/QUESTIONS.md Open the file as written

Equity Flow v4 — Diligence Questions (Public Site Review)

Questions the review panel needs answered, derived from ChatGPT's review of the current public website (public/equity-flow.html, public/equity.html) as of August 2026 — the deferred-interest, non-recourse loan structure, not the equity-share product killed in v3. Source document: chatgpt public site feedback/chatgpt_initial_public_website_review.txt. Grouped by discipline. No analysis — questions only. Each question traces back to a section of the source doc in brackets; cross-references to related questions in other sections are noted where the source itself treats an issue as spanning domains.

Materials every agent should read before answering: this file's section for them, the live pages at public/equity-flow.html and public/equity.html, and the full source feedback doc for context.


1. Retail Customer

Equity Tap Comparison Accuracy

  1. Does the Equity Tap cash-out refi "total interest" figure currently mix interest on the full refinanced first-mortgage balance with incremental interest on the new cash drawn, making it non-comparable to the HELOC/HE-loan/Equity Flow figures shown alongside it? If so, recompute and decompose it into: interest on replacement of the existing balance, incremental interest on new cash, closing costs, lost rate-lock value, and total household cash-flow change. [§10]
  2. The "Rate lock destroyed: $X lost" figure has no stated methodology. Determine whether it represents undiscounted incremental interest, present value, nominal lifetime cost, or expected holding-period cost, and add that label to the page. [§10]
  3. Equity Tap models the full access amount as drawn immediately and left unpaid for 10 years, while the core Equity Flow page presents scheduled monthly advances — economically different products. Should both pages model identical proceeds timing, or should Equity Tap's result be explicitly labeled a "lump-sum variant" distinct from the monthly product? [§10]
  4. Rewrite the comparison table's tax-deductibility row: it currently reduces a fact-dependent question to a few words. Recommend replacement language reflecting that deductibility depends on use of proceeds, taxpayer circumstances, applicable law, and whether interest has actually been paid. [§10; see also Tax Attorney Q20]

Homeowner-Page Language

  1. Is "A paycheck from your house" — paired with a "+$2,950/month" visual beside negative HELOC/HE-loan payments — misleading without an equally prominent statement that these are loan proceeds and every advance increases the balance secured by the home? Recommend specific copy fixes. [§11; see also Securities/Consumer-Finance Q22]
  2. Is "money you already had along the way" accurate, given the homeowner had home equity, not cash, before the loan converted part of it into cash while creating a lien and interest expense? Recommend replacement language that doesn't imply withdrawal from an owned account. [§11]
  3. The Promise List states "the only variable... is the day you choose to sell." That's only true under a fixed advance-and-repayment path. List every other variable that can change the printed balance (stopped or shrunk advances, voluntary prepayments, fees or recoverable servicing advances, property-protection expenses, default/workout costs) and recommend a qualifying disclosure. [§11]
  4. Should "Your deposits cannot be switched off" remain on the page before legal, trustee, bankruptcy, and funding counsel have confirmed in writing that the trust arrangement supports that promise under every contemplated scenario? What interim qualifying language, if any, is appropriate until those opinions exist? [§11]

2. Credit Investor

Return Profile and Negative Convexity

  1. Model the negative-convexity profile the source describes: borrowers with improving circumstances, falling rates, or strong appreciation prepay early (investor loses the high-coupon asset); borrowers in stagnant, long-hold, high-PIK-balance scenarios have no incentive to prepay (investor bears the non-recourse shortfall). Quantify how portfolio-level returns change once the full probability distribution of exit dates and home-price paths is incorporated — not just the acknowledged "cushion goes negative between years 15-20 under flat HPI" observation. [§3]
  2. Is the 10.25% coupon sufficient once negative convexity is priced in? Show the sensitivity. [§3]

Yield Presentation

  1. Build and present each of the following as a distinct figure, and stop presenting the 10.25% coupon as "realized yield": gross borrower coupon; gross unlevered asset IRR; loss-adjusted asset IRR; servicing-adjusted net asset yield; warehouse-levered equity IRR; whole-loan purchaser yield; securitization residual yield; and returns under adverse-selection/prepayment stress scenarios. [§4; see also Securities/Consumer-Finance Q21]

Prefunded Trust Economics

  1. Produce a monthly sources-and-uses schedule for the prefunded trust showing: investor cash funded, borrower advances, trust investment earnings, warehouse borrowings, interest expense, unused commitment, advance rates, required reserves, and equity capital consumed. Reconcile the page's two capital-utilization claims — "average capital outstanding is approximately half the commitment" vs. "scheduled commitments achieve roughly 90% capital utilization" — do they use different denominators, and if so, which one governs investor returns? [§5]
  2. If the full advance commitment is funded into the trust on day one but only a fraction has been advanced to the borrower, what yield does the undrawn cash earn, and does it offset the investor's cash drag? Model the net effect on realized fund-level return. [§5]
  3. What warehouse-lender perfected-interest structure is contemplated for both the originated loans and the undrawn trust assets, and is it achievable given the trust's bankruptcy-remote design? [§12 Funding trust; see also Real-Estate/Title Q36]
  4. What assets may the trustee invest undrawn cash in, and what happens to the fund's return if interest rates change materially while cash sits unreleased in trust? [§12 Funding trust]

Capital Strategy and Moat

  1. Beyond the diagnosis already stated (the product depends on takeout execution, ~$9-10M equity-funded warehouse carry per $100M volume, ceases to compete if takeout misses timing/economics, gating target of ≥85% advance at ≤6.5% weighted coupon): what specific evidence — binding forward-flow agreement, committed warehouse with defined eligibility/takeout protection, a capitalized pilot able to hold loans through demonstrated exits, or rating-agency preassessment — currently exists? Which of these is the minimum bar to consider the capital strategy real rather than assumed? [§8; see also Insurance/Actuarial Q51]
  2. Provide actual funnel data supporting the "owned distribution" moat claim: monthly unique users, calculator completion rate, percentage meeting the underwriting box, lead-to-application conversion, application-to-close conversion, expected CAC, channel mix, time to close, abandonment reasons, and borrower willingness to accept a 10%-plus fixed rate after counseling. Does current or projected CAC beat banks, reverse-mortgage lenders, and HEI companies by a meaningful margin, or is "education-first funnel" currently just an assertion? [§9; see also Product Operator Q46]

Economics

  1. What APR results from the actual advance schedule (not just the stated coupon)? What prepayment curve is assumed, and what are expected and stressed loss rates? How does geographic HPI dispersion affect portfolio losses, and what happens under simultaneous flat HPI, high insurance inflation, and falling property liquidity? [§12 Economics]

3. Tax Attorney

  1. Once the legal ownership of undrawn trust cash is established (see Estate/Bankruptcy Q37), does interest on the borrower's balance accrue only from the date of each monthly release, or from the date the full commitment is funded into the trust? What tax and disclosure consequences follow from each answer? [§5]
  2. Does the quoted 10.25% coupon compound monthly, daily, or annually, and are financed fees included in the interest-bearing balance for purposes of characterizing the payment stream? [§12 Economics; see also Credit Investor Q18]
  3. Confirm or refine the recommended replacement language for the Equity Tap comparison table's tax-deductibility row: "potentially deductible, subject to applicable law and individual circumstances, and only once interest has actually been paid." [§10; see also Retail Customer Q4]

4. Securities / Consumer-Finance Attorney

Investor-Facing Disclosure

  1. Is labeling the 10.25% contractual coupon as "realized yield" to prospective investors — without disclosing that it assumes full contractual recovery, no servicing costs, no foreclosure/ property-preservation costs, no financing cost, no trust cash drag, no originator/administrator expenses, no delayed liquidation, and no losses — a misleading statement of investment performance under applicable securities-disclosure standards? [§4; see also Credit Investor Q11]

Consumer-Facing Marketing

  1. Do the consumer-language issues flagged for the homeowner page ("A paycheck from your house" paired with a positive-cash-flow visual; "money you already had"; "the only variable is the day you choose to sell") create UDAAP or state deceptive-advertising exposure independent of the copy fixes recommended by Retail Customer (Q5-Q7)? [§11]

Age-Based and State Licensing

  1. Can this product legally be offered to homeowners below age 62 in every intended launch state? Which states classify it as a reverse mortgage, a proprietary reverse mortgage, a conventional second mortgage, or another category — and does that classification change state by state? [§12 Legal and regulatory]
  2. Are there age minimums under any state constitution or statute that would apply regardless of how the product is federally classified? [§12 Legal and regulatory]
  3. What principal-limit, counseling, appraisal, and disclosure requirements apply, and do they differ from the requirements already contemplated for the 62+ HECM-style precedent this product is derived from? [§12 Legal and regulatory]
  4. Does "no monthly payment" trigger special ability-to-repay analysis or high-cost-mortgage treatment under TILA or state equivalents? [§12 Legal and regulatory]
  5. Is the 10.25% rate, inclusive of financed fees, permissible under state usury and high-cost-mortgage thresholds in every target state? [§12 Legal and regulatory]
  6. Is Texas the only state where the product cannot be offered, or are there other state-constitutional or statutory exclusions? [§12 Legal and regulatory]
  7. When co-owning spouses differ in age or title status, does that affect eligibility, disclosure, or non-recourse treatment? [§12 Legal and regulatory; see also Estate/Bankruptcy Q41]
  8. What specific legal opinions currently support non-recourse treatment of the product, and are they sufficient to survive a challenge in every target state? [§12 Legal and regulatory; see also Real-Estate/Title Q36]
  9. Who is the licensed originator, and does noteworth's role (platform, distributor, potential broker or lead generator) require licensing in any target state? [§12 Commercial; see also Product Operator Q44]

5. Real-Estate / Title Attorney

  1. If the senior (first) mortgage becomes delinquent, can the Equity Flow servicer advance senior payments, taxes, insurance, or property-preservation costs on the borrower's behalf? If so, do those advances accrue interest, and where do they sit in priority within the Equity Flow balance and against the senior lien? [§12 Collateral and servicing]
  2. What covenants require the borrower to maintain the property, keep taxes current, and maintain insurance, and what is the enforcement mechanism if they don't? [§12 Collateral and servicing]
  3. How is "permanent move-out" established as a triggering occupancy event, and at what point does renting the property (partial or full) become an occupancy event? [§12 Collateral and servicing]
  4. What is the foreclosure and liquidation timeline by state once an occupancy or default event occurs, and who controls the decision to sell when expected proceeds are insufficient to cover both the senior lien and the Equity Flow balance? [§12 Collateral and servicing]
  5. Does the trust's bankruptcy-remote structure allow warehouse lenders to obtain a perfected interest in both the originated loan and the undrawn trust assets, and does that affect lien priority against the borrower's senior mortgage? [§12 Funding trust; see also Credit Investor Q14, Securities/Consumer-Finance Q31]

6. Estate / Bankruptcy Attorney

  1. Who economically owns the undrawn cash sitting in the prefunded, bankruptcy-remote trust before it's released to the borrower on schedule — the funding investor, the trust itself, the borrower (subject to scheduled release), or a separate bankruptcy-remote SPE? And who receives the investment income earned on that undrawn cash in the meantime? This characterization determines: when a loan advance is considered "made"; whether interest can accrue only after monthly release; bankruptcy treatment (of the borrower's estate and of the trust); setoff risk; consumer disclosures; accounting treatment; warehouse eligibility; and whether the cash can be reinvested. [§5; §12 Funding trust]
  2. Is the trust genuinely bankruptcy-remote from the originator, the servicer, the depositor, AND the investor — all four, not just the originator? [§12 Funding trust]
  3. What happens to a borrower's unreleased future scheduled advances if the borrower files bankruptcy — does the automatic stay, a trustee's avoidance powers, or a recharacterization argument put the funded-but-undrawn trust assets at risk? [§5]
  4. How are heirs handled after the borrower's death — what is the notice, cooperation, and settlement process, and what happens if heirs are hostile, uncooperative, or unreachable? [§12 Collateral and servicing; see also Product Operator Q48]
  5. When co-owning spouses differ in age or title status, does the non-recourse and trust-funding structure treat them identically, or does one spouse's death, divorce, or incapacity change what heirs or the surviving spouse can enforce? [§12 Legal and regulatory; see also Securities/Consumer-Finance Q30]

7. Product Operator

Underwriting

  1. Beyond "zero credit-score minimums" and the stated current-senior-mortgage-plus-12-month-clean-payment-history requirement, does underwriting also examine: bankruptcies and foreclosures; tax liens; judgments; delinquent property taxes; insurance claims history and insurability; HOA liens; borrower liquidity; property condition; senior-loan terms and future senior amortization; geographic concentration; disaster exposure; and the borrower's stated reason for needing proceeds? Which of these are checked today, and which are gaps? [§6]
  2. Since there's no scheduled Equity Flow payment to miss, the real behavioral risk is failure to maintain the property, remain insured, pay taxes, keep the senior mortgage current, or cooperate with an eventual sale. What is the monitoring and intervention plan for each of these, beyond Bill Shield (which only covers taxes/insurance, and only when elected or required)? [§6]

Trust and Advance Operations

  1. What happens operationally if scheduled advances exceed available trust assets because of operational loss or fraud — is there a contingency funding source, and who bears the shortfall in the interim? [§12 Funding trust]
  2. What is the fully loaded cost to originate one loan — origination, counseling, appraisal, title, recording, and servicing — and what portion is borrower-paid versus investor-funded? What are expected annual servicing expenses per position? [§12 Economics; see also Credit Investor Q18]

Commercial and Scale

  1. Who is the licensed originator and who services the loans in practice — is noteworth intended to become a lender, broker, software provider, or lead generator, and has that determination been made? [§12 Commercial; see also Securities/Consumer-Finance Q32]
  2. What revenue does noteworth earn per loan, and is it recognized at origination or over the life of the asset? [§12 Commercial]
  3. What is the expected CAC, what percentage of Equity Tap users actually qualify under the underwriting box, and what percentage would accept a 10.25%+ fixed rate after counseling? Is there real consumer testing behind the assumed preference for a monthly-paycheck structure, or is that assumed? [§12 Commercial; see also Credit Investor Q17]
  4. Who bears repurchase risk for defective loans (origination errors, misrepresentation, etc.), and what is the expected first-year and steady-state origination volume? [§12 Commercial]
  5. What is the operational plan for heirs, probate attorneys, and estate executors after a borrower's death, including uncooperative or hostile heirs? [§12 Collateral and servicing; see also Estate/Bankruptcy Q41]

8. Insurance / Actuarial

  1. Build a competing-risks exit model incorporating: voluntary home sale; refinance/prepayment; death; permanent move-out; divorce; entry into assisted living; foreclosure by the senior lender; borrower bankruptcy; and modification/workout. Does the current 8-14-year modeled exit window for the 45-61 target age band hold up once these are modeled explicitly, or does it need revision? [§7]
  2. The target cohort (45-61) is materially younger than the traditional 62+ reverse-mortgage precedent this product's duration assumptions are derived from. Quantify how that difference likely changes the exit-timing distribution: fewer mortality exits, more employment- and divorce-driven transitions, more rate-driven refinancing, and generally wider variance in hold duration. Can the 62+ precedent's duration assumptions be inherited at all, or do they need to be rebuilt from scratch for this cohort? [§7]
  3. The materials state directly held whole loans are "expected" to receive approximately 0.7% Schedule B capital treatment. Is that confirmed in writing by any regulator, rating agency, or the insurer counterparty itself, or is it still an unconfirmed assumption? What is required to move it from "expected" to "confirmed," and how does the actual RBC/capital charge compare if the more conservative Schedule BA treatment applies instead? [§8; see also Credit Investor Q16]
  4. Does the underwriting population described in the marketing (cannot obtain a HELOC, lacks conventional income documentation, has experienced unemployment, has high carrying costs, cannot safely take on another payment) constitute adverse selection relative to the actuarial assumptions underlying the coupon and loss models? Quantify the expected difference in default/loss behavior between this population and a general equity-rich homeowner population. [§6; see also Product Operator Q43]

Red Team

Not assigned a question subset. Per the established process (see ../equity flow v3 - KILL/ and ../../RUNBOOK.md Stage 1, Wave 2), red-team runs last, against the live site, this file, and all eight other agents' completed reviews, with the standing job of finding the failure mode the panel missed.


How this file gets used

Mirrors the Stage 1 / Stage 2 pattern from ../equity flow v3 - KILL/ (see ../../RUNBOOK.md):

  1. Wave 1 — dispatch the eight discipline agents above in parallel. Each reads its section of this file plus the live pages, and writes its complete answers to reviews/equity flow v4/<agent-name>.md.
  2. Wave 2 — dispatch red-team against the live site, this file, and all eight completed reviews. Writes reviews/equity flow v4/red-team.md.
  3. Cross-exam — give each of the nine reviewers all the other reports and ask what they dispute and what new problems any proposed fix creates. Writes reviews/equity flow v4/crossexam-<agent-name>.md.

Log progress to reviews/equity flow v4/STATUS.md after each wave, per the RUNBOOK execution rules.