Data room / Successor concepts and their reviews
Version 2.1 concept: open line of credit
concepts/EQUITY-FLOW-LINE-V21-CONCEPT.md Open the file as written
EQUITY FLOW LINE — CONCEPT v2.1
One instrument, two modes: the line is the product; the paycheck is a feature
Successor/extension to HomeDraw v2 (the tenure product on the current beta page). v2 survived legal review; its limitation is product-market shape: the target customer often wants flexible, temporary, self-directed draws — "bleed my equity on my terms" — not an 84-month committed schedule. v2.1 generalizes: a deferred-interest, non-recourse, second-lien line of credit, with the tenure schedule reframed as an autopay feature on the line.
1. Consumer terms
- Instrument: recorded second-lien deed of trust securing a revolving line; Reg Z reverse-mortgage classification target (repayment at sale / permanent move-out / death); openly a loan.
- Line sizing: CLTV ≤ 60% at approval; line capped so that (senior projection + full-line-drawn + accrual) ≤ 75% CLTV at a 7-yr horizon at flat prices (same box as v2).
- Draw modes: (a) SCHEDULED — "$X/month" autopay, prefunded rolling 12 months into a bankruptcy-remote trust, contractually unpausable (the v2 guarantee, preserved); (b) ON-DEMAND — any amount ≥ $500, funded within 5 business days, best-efforts above a guaranteed program reserve floor.
- Pricing: single fixed rate on drawn balances only (target 9.75% at scale; ~10.25% phase-1), monthly compounding, fully deferred. No origination fee, no annual fee, no draw fee, no prepay penalty, no inactivity fee. Rate-only.
- Repayment: any amount, any time; balance due only at sale/move-out/ death; non-recourse capped at net proceeds. All v2 protections carry over (counseling, all-spouse execution, no arbitration clause, no occupancy covenants beyond primary-residence-at-approval, printed worst-case schedules for the scheduled mode; on-demand draws confirmed with a plain-dollar cost preview before funding).
- Approval ≠ commitment: an approved-but-never-drawn line consumes no fund capacity and costs the customer nothing, forever. Capacity reserves attach at FIRST draw.
2. Funding mechanics (from line_funding_model.py — results in
LINE-FUNDING-RESULTS.txt)
- Required consumer rate = blended funding + 60bps servicing + 50bps EL + 50bps margin + origination amortization + reserve drag = rho x (1-u)/u x (hurdle - cash yield).
- Grid results: hard-committed lines (rho 25%) need 10.5–11.3% even post-takeout → rejected. Guaranteed-core+shell (rho ~10%) at u ≥ 50% → ~9.7%; approval-not-commitment (rho ~5%) → ~9.45%.
- Phase gating: pre-takeout blended funding (~9.3%) makes any flexible line infeasible (11.2–12.6% required). Therefore: Phase 1 = tenure-only (v2), u≈90% by construction, ~10.25%. Rated takeout at ≥85%/≤6.5% unlocks Phase 2 = the Line at ~9.75%. The tenure product is the utilization engine that finances the flexible one.
- Origination cost is load-bearing: net spread ≈ 132bps; breakeven drawn-dollar-years = origination/0.0132. At $5,300 traditional cost a small-draw account never breaks even; requirement: ≤ $1,000, target ~$500 (AVM valuation, e-close/e-record, no appraisal ≤ 50% CLTV).
- Servicing: revolving PIK master-trust style structures (credit-card ABS / pre-08 HELOC ABS mechanics) contemplated for takeout; to be validated.
3. Altruism scorecard (at 9.75%, no fees)
- $12K unemployment bridge repaid yr 3: $3,241 total cost; available DURING unemployment (no income qualification) — the only product on the market with that property.
- $40K card payoff repaid yr 6: $31,630 with zero mandatory payments vs ~$55K interest plus minimums keeping the cards.
- Full deferral to a yr-12 sale: $88K on $40K — expensive and disclosed; repayment timing is the customer's lever and the UI shows the meter.
- Disclosure duties: secured-vs-unsecured trade on card consolidation; compounding meter on every statement and in-app.
4. Open questions for adversarial review (the honest kill-risks)
- Utilization distribution & wrong-way draws: draws likely correlate with borrower distress and macro stress (2008/2020 HELOC draw-runs). Does u spike exactly when warehouse capacity tightens? What does a draw-run + funding-freeze joint scenario do to the 5-day promise and to reserve sizing? Is rho=10% honest or fantasy?
- Adverse selection at the draw: no income qual means the marginal on-demand draw skews toward pre-delinquency households; senior-mortgage default follows. Does EL=50bps survive?
- Warehouse & takeout structure: will any warehouse lend against undrawn commitments? Do revolving master-trust structures work for PIK second liens (credit-card analogy vs the pre-08 HELOC ABS graveyard)?
- Dormancy economics: approval-at-no-cost invites huge approved-never- drawn books; marketing CAC per FUNDED account explodes if conversion to first draw is low. What CAC/activation assumptions make it work?
- Phase transition: does offering the Line cannibalize Phase-1 tenure originations before the takeout exists (everyone waits for the better product)? Sequencing/communication risk.
- Rate integrity: do the corrections above keep the consumer rate ≤ ~10.5% (the HELOC-competitiveness ceiling from the v2 reviews), or does the flexible product price itself back out of existence?
END OF CONCEPT v2.1